
A great way to begin an inaugural presentation is by sharing a secret. Katherine I. admitted that when she chose Philip Roth, she mistakenly thought he was the author of Empire Falls (written by Richard Russo). After realizing her error, she was too deep into Roth to switch. What an unexpected literary journey it became!
Philip Roth (1933-2018) was born into a Jewish family in New Jersey. His Jewish background and New Jersey setting often found their way into his writing. During his lifetime, Roth was considered by many as the “greatest living American writer.” However, his work received polarizing reviews. It was widely criticized for its raw yet satirical views on middle-class Jewish-American life, explicit sexual content, and misogynistic portrayals of women.
Katherine and other club members question whether Roth’s reputation as a misogynist matters. Does it change the quality of his writing and his depiction of the era? At the time, other male writers explored similar themes and stereotypes, including John Updike, Norman Mailer, Vladimir Nabokov, and Canada’s own Mordecai Richler.
From his thirty-one books, Katherine curated and discussed a fabulous selection of Roth’s works: Good-Bye, Columbus (1959), best-selling Portnoy’s Complaint (1969), The Prague Orgy (1985), Operation Shylock: A Confession (1993), I Married a Communist (1998), Indignation (2008), and Nemesis (2010). According to Katherine, Sabbath’s Theatre (1995) and American Pastoral (1997) are Roth’s best books.
Roth won many awards including the prestigious Pulitzer Prize for Fiction (1998), the Man Booker International Prize (2011), and the National Book Award for Fiction (1960 and 1995). Although Roth was a top contender for the Nobel Prize in Literature, his controversial themes, content, and portrayals may have contributed to the Swedish Academy not selecting him as a winner.
After reading Roth’s works, Katherine describes his writing as character-driven, dialogue-rich, provocative, dense, and defiant of convention. Whether or not his raw, sexually explicit style is for every reader, it certainly gives us something to think about.
Written by Mooréa G.








