
Shawna M.’s presentation on Japanese writer Yukio Mishima on March 17th was an insightful and nuanced synthesis of four decades of reading and discussing his works.
Three questions constituted her presentation’s scaffolding: why Mishima didn’t win the Nobel Prize in Literature, what are hallmarks of his writing, and is he relevant today (he died by seppuku in 1970, age 46).
Mishima was nominated five times for the Nobel Prize in Literature during the 1960s (Wikipedia). He tackled very controversial topics, such as glorious (suicide) versus ignoble death (dying in hospital), sexual ambiguity/eroticism, cruelty/brutality versus perfection, imperialism versus boorish democracy. Moreover, Mishima was in the public eye: a model, actor, Kendo master, Samurai acolyte, the subject of lurid photos that he arranged. Was he too politically or socially controversial to win? Was he too young?
Three books are especially noteworthy in his literary evolution. The success of Confessions of a Mask (1949) allowed Mishima to travel Europe and the Americas extensively. His outer and inner worlds expanded exponentially with new ideas, possibilities, and challenges. This may also have been the start of gay relationships, but Shawna cautioned there is much debate about his bisexuality (which, at times, overshadows discussions about his writings).
In The Temple of the Golden Pavilion (1956), the protagonist, a monk, becomes psychologically unhinged by the Temple’s beauty contra friends’ mutual abusiveness. He eventually sets fire to the temple. Shawna noted the concept of “a beautiful, violent, futile gesture” was introduced here and it informed Mishima’s later years. The Sound of Waves(1959), by contrast, describes the idealized Japan Mishima believed is possible, wherein morality, hard work, and community are foundational.
Yes, Mishima is relevant today. The Sea of Fertility was written in the last years of his life and is a tetralogy. Through the characters’ lives, the personal philosophy of Mishima—a man of many contradictions—is helpfully explained. He skillfully interweaves Japanese and European literary techniques. Moods are created not by merely stating them, but through evocative metaphors. He tenaciously and unapologetically explores the proverbial “fine line” between good and evil. While his topics, plots, and characters may seem too daunting to engage, Shawna praised Mishima’s work as both profound and accessible. She concluded her engaging presentation by reading excerpts from three books to share the imagery, clarity, and beauty of his writing.
Written by Barbara R.








